It’s Not Easy Being Green

I don’t expect a medal, but I changed all the light bulbs in my house to energy efficient ones. I also recycle occasionally, and I repeatedly remind my kids to turn off the lights when they leave a room. I’m also seriously considering buying reusable grocery bags. I’ve paused to look at a couple different styles and everything. But all of this hoopla about “going green” has me feeling a little bullied.

So I stumbled upon this article by Charles Krauthammer when I was stirring my compost heap out back. In it he talks about how environmentalism is the new socialism. It’s really interesting. You should read the entire thing, but if you don’t have time because you’re too busy charging your electric car, let me give you some highlights:

***

” ‘The largest threat to freedom, democracy, the market economy and prosperity,” warns Czech President Vaclav Klaus, “is no longer socialism. It is, instead, the ambitious, arrogant, unscrupulous ideology of environmentalism.’ ”

***

“If you doubt the arrogance, you haven’t seen that Newsweek cover story that declared the global warming debate over. Consider: If Newton’s laws of motion could, after 200 years of unfailing experimental and experiential confirmation, be overthrown, it requires religious fervor to believe that global warming — infinitely more untested, complex and speculative — is a closed issue.”

***

“Only Monday, a British parliamentary committee proposed that every citizen be required to carry a carbon card that must be presented, under penalty of law, when buying gasoline, taking an airplane or using electricity. The card contains your yearly carbon ration to be drawn down with every purchase, every trip, every swipe.
There’s no greater social power than the power to ration. And, other than rationing food, there is no greater instrument of social control than rationing energy, the currency of just about everything one does and uses in an advanced society.”

***

Again, you should really read the entire article. It leads you through the socialism/environmental connection and offers real suggestions to the environmental issue based on a “global warming agnostic’s” point of view which directly questions The Church of Environmentalism dogma.

What is annoying to me is how environmentalism is everywhere and preaches to you like you’re some kind of idiot. Do you remember when NBC “went green” for a week? What, you don’t watch a lot of TV? Let me fill you in. For one entire week, the Thursday night line-up (from My Name is Earl to the Office, 30 Rock, Scrubs, and ER) talked about ways we can save the environment. Even the peacock at the bottom of the screen was all green. (Hmmm, not the color of the rainbow, but one singular color. I’m sure there’s some symbolism there). The writers wrote little sub-plots that incorporated tips for all of us common-folk to use in our daily lives. Our favorite characters talked about how much energy was saved by changing a simple light-bulb or how riding a bike or taking the bus to work saves both money and the WORLD. The entire world. It was pathetic and so heavy-handed that its infomercial script took me out of the story. (Only 30 Rock really pulled it off effortlessly, but that’s because Tina Fey’s a genius). It made me want to litter. I didn’t, but I totally thought about it.

Regardless of what you believe, it is frightening to consider how no one wants to really discuss all the possibilities of global warming–you’re made to feel like an idiot if you bring up any questions about it. Not to mention the “celebrity pressure” that has reached epic proportions. There is no debate, and that’s frightening. Are we so quick to let ourselves be regulated on how much we can travel, what we should eat, what kind of light we should read by, how cool or warm our house should be and what kind of story lines we watch on our favorite television programs?

16 Responses to “It’s Not Easy Being Green”
  1. rachey says:

    Okay, NBC’s “green week” was incredibly annoying, and stupid. I just figure I will do my best to be as friendly to the environment as possible, regardless of the global warming threat or non threat. I think it is our responsibility to take care of the earth that God made for us. And to me that includes recycling as much as I can (cause who can deny that huge trash piles of non recyclable goods is a bad thing?) and be responsible and reasonable with my driving and power use. It bothers me when global warming becomes a political issue (ie. Al Gore sucks, or something along those lines) because what it really comes down to is just being decent and good to the earth.

  2. Karen says:

    Thanks for this post Lisa, and for some good things to think about.

    I’ve been using the compact florescent bulbs, but now I’m concerned about them. They have mercury in them. Have you read about how to dispose of them? They are hazardous waste. You are supposed to take them to a special waste center. And if you break one you are supposed to evacuate the room?! I’m considering going back to the energy wasting regular bulbs.

    This is why I think it is good to do some research ourselves, find out about things, so we aren’t just jumping on the popular band wagon. I wish I had done some research before switching to compact bulbs.

    I recycle what I can. I use reusable bags to shop. I’m trying to do what I can. But I’m trying to learn a little bit about ‘why’ before I start (or stop) doing something “green”.

  3. aubrey says:

    Love the blog, this is my first response to it.

    My husband’s family does not believe in global warming. They think it’s a crock. At least, one very vocal sis-in-law thinks so and generally everyone else follows her lead. She is also onse sho thinks “organic” is a four letter word.
    My sister, on the other hand, buys into it–lives in southern cali, very environmentally aware, etc.
    I am somewhere in the middle.
    Definitely don’t agree with the coersive (sp?) tactics of evening television, or with the carbon card idea…seriously??? Are we really so egotstical to think we are saving the whole world by replacing our bulbs? I do think it’s a good idea to be responsible and not wasteful with resources and certainly we need to be wise stewards. But I also think that God created this world to last us as long as needed until the end of time. He forsaw our use of energy, plastic bags, disposable diapers, water, lightbulbs…you name it. I figure as long as we are here and doing our best it’s pretty much taken care of and not something to get so worked up over.

    Besides, why else would the earth burn at the Lord’s coming? There’s a lot of trash to incinerate.

  4. Mak says:

    I agree that it is annoying how being “green” is a new, trendy psudo-religion (like kaballah?). I hate it for the same reasons that I hate movies like Happy Feet. The “green” message is commonly packaged with “if you don’t do this, you are killing cute, baby penguins”. I don’t think guilt is a way to get people to do anything.

    I think there are a lot of things we can and should do- use less energy, recycle more, and in general be more responsible stewards of this earth that our Heavenly Father gave us. But I don’t think we need to scare kids (and ourselves) into doing it.

    Besides, I’ve heard that the there is a greater greenhouse threat from cow, ummm… toots. Apparently methane is worse than carbon emissions. But try telling people to eat less beef/dairy- it is way sexier and better poltics to blame big companies and China and cars than red-blooded, beef-eating americans and farmers…

  5. sister gina says:

    I hate the color of light from compact bulbs and I refuse to tote my own tote to the grocery store because I’d need about 10 of them each trip! However, I think it is wise to be mindful of what we consume, not only because of the impact on the earth, but because it can save you money. I’m fiscally practical. I won’t do something because Brangelina tells me to, but I will do it if it makes sense to me. Good thoughts, Lisa!

  6. jennie w. says:

    I’ve thought about using those grocery bags, because everybody here in Texas uses them (peer pressure, I know). But they’re really not cute enough for me.

  7. bek says:

    Good thoughts.

    The worst is when your 7 year old is TOTALLY on the green bandwagon (thank you public school!!) and you get it ALL DAY LONG. I’ll admit, I do bring my own bags to the store (but that is because they are no longer given out at our stores…new law) and we recycle. I refuse to compost. I hate the smell/flies….

    it makes me feel like I am supposed to be talking about something that I don’t know much about. It also makes me feel guilty for wrapping my disposable diapers in the the now outlawed plastic shopping bags before I throw them away. I am murdering earth.

    oh well.

  8. Shaunda says:

    I really like Aubrey’s comments and it made me think of a scripture that I found one day that has really impacted my life. During high school I had a teacher who said that it was “socially irresponsible” to have large families and that the earth could not sustain all the people. He talked about zero population. That really upset me because I came from a family of 6 children and I really believed that the Lord created the earth and had made enough supplies for all of His children. When I read this scripture during my freshman year of college I knew that I had found my answer. I believe that it applies to many social aspects such as abortion, population control, and environmentalism. While I think we should be responsible, I also know that the Lord has prepared enough for us.
    The scripture is D&C 104:17 “For the earth is full, and there is enough and to spare; yea, I prepared all things, and have given unto the children of men to be agents unto themselves”.

  9. RobertValentine says:

    Frankly, it leaves me hot under the collar.

  10. christopher clark says:

    I’m only green because celebrities are. Let’s face, I do whatever celebrities tell me to!

  11. talitha says:

    yeah, this is a tough issue for me. I agree that we are being promoted to and advertised to and pummeled to “go Green”. I see it in the questions my elementary school children are told to come home and ask us. But, I also believe that we are to show gratitude for the earth we have been given, and to be good stewards of it. I try to offer my children a balanced point of view–not the rabid “people are killing the planet” line, and not the Rush Limbaugh “We’re humans, we’re in charge, we can do whatever we want” line, either.

  12. Lynn says:

    I am totally negative on fluorescent lighting ever since I found out it increases irritability/hyperactive levels in children who are “hyper”….that was the term we used in the 60″s! Several of our “quiet, subdued children” were considered in this category….we didn’t need anything to make them more active. I think today’s mom’s should know that….Do you also know that many food colors set these same kids off? You can tell I did some research….and it paid off! Thanks for letting me vent….NO FLUORESCENTS for my kids! (Rachel, I can’t log in with just “Lynn”…I hope my comments show up with just Lynn…thanks :)

  13. Sharolyn says:

    I think that part of the reason gas prices are so high is that we have been irresponsible as a country with the way we use our resources and have failed to conserve. It’s time we all started being much more responsible in everything we do. I’ve been using the fluorescent light bulbs for years, and actually like them and have saved. We also can live the word of wisdom and eat less meat (especially beef) and buy local as much as possible. There are a lot of things people could do that would not affect their pocket book negatively. I participate in a work share from an organic community supported agriculture farm. For 23 weeks I work 4 hours a week for a big bag of wonderful produce each week and a bunch of extra tomatoes to bottle each August. I’m busy, but it’s important to feeding my family healthfully and good for our community and planet. Really, everyone, it’s not nice for people to be bullying or probably overboard for what NBC did, but we do need to do more. It’s not just about global warming.

  14. Mhef says:

    Shaunda I just had a similar experience with a friend who had blogged about how she and her wife (yes, that’s correct) have chosen not to have children in order to “do their part in not creating more consumers”. Then she noted how some of her friends (me!) were working on baby #5 and that their decision might not really be doing any good.
    I’d never thought of a big family as socially irresponsible and a conversation with my dad years ago about how he felt that people should only replace themselves (ie. have two children) caused me to research the idea, which actually leads to extinction. So I don’t worry that we are over-burdening the world with our almost family of seven. And thankfully he’s nice to ALL of my kids, not just the first two.

    And like RobertValentine said, the new push for the environment gets my hackles up mostly because of the source in Mr. Inconvenient Truth himself. Which, if you watch Glenn Beck at all, he’s pretty much refuted most of what the ol’ inventor of the internet has said. Seems like the convergence of the energy crisis, higher food prices, and the point in they natural cycle of things that has ice melting at the poles has brought many to near hysteria. Lucky Al!


  15. [...] don’t want to get Lisa mad, but I love reusable shopping bags. Unfortunately for the environment, I don’t often use them [...]

  16. Angela says:

    Actually, gas prices are so high because we’ve gone so environmentally overboard that we can’t even explore for oil and natural gas on our own land. That’s how socialism works, slowly take away freedoms with initiatives that sound wonderful. Who doesn’t want to save the environment? Who doesn’t want everyone to have free healthcare? If you don’t want those things: Why do you hate the environment? Why do you hate people? Ugh. I’m not wasteful, that’s why I’m such a pack-rat. I finish my dinner even if I’m stuffed because I don’t like to “waste” anything. I’m stocking up on incandescent light bulbs before the government mandates “energy efficient” ones. Last time I checked America was a free country and they can’t make me use poisoned light bulbs. Like McCain says: That’s not an energy policy, it’s a public service announcement. Or at least it should be.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment. First time users must register before logging in.