Guest Post: Rachel

It was bound to happen: a Rachel who is not me is our guest blogger. Don’t get confused. But this new Rachel has also done something I have never done. She has borne children without painkillers. I am always very curious about this perspective and invite you to welcome it, and the “new” Rachel, this morning.


Birth and Art

When I gave birth for the first time, I didn’t realize how lucky I was. Well, that might be subjective. I gave birth in Arizona in one of the first free standing birth centers there. It was a beautiful place that I felt comfortable in without the stark floors and drab walls of a hospital. All they did there were natural births…they knew how to help women with a natural birth. I was in 24 hours of labor in pain, and surprisingly enough I came away from that with a very positive view of birth and my abilities to give birth. At that time, I didn’t know that things were done differently at the hospital. I didn’t know that having a natural birth was something that most women did not do. So, I had my second there. With both of these births I found great meaning and application to my beginning life as a mother.

Then I moved and the birthing possibilities were not the same. It was either at home, which I didn’t feel entirely comfortable with, or in the hospital. I did not mind the hospital as much, but no one knew quite what to do with a woman who did not take pain medication. They simply had not had enough experience. It was at this point that I began to really explore why I still chose to have medication free births. Why would any of us choose to feel pain when it can easily be taken away? It’s a question that I’m not sure I can still answer, except to say that somehow, I have found meaning in that pain.

This exploration has also led me to write my own blog…one in which I have explored the meaning of pain, fear, becoming a mother, and how this applies to motherhood. Part of this exploration has also led me to explore art in the context of birth also. I have felt like the meaning in birth and motherhood can be very difficult to explain and touches on emotional aspects that can sometimes only be expressed by art, either in writing, painting, sewing etc. Explaining the joy that came to me is like trying to explain why seeing the smile on my child for the first time makes me so happy. It is one of those experiences that has the ability to touch the inner core of who we are as women. As such, sometimes the only way we can express this is through art.

I myself am not an artist, but I appreciate and enjoy looking at and experiencing other peoples art. As a part of my own exploration, I began collecting pieces that showed what birth and motherhood meant to them. You can find that on my blog.

I am still accepting more and see this an ongoing project, so if any of you would like to submit something send it my way. I would love to see how this process has changed you and how you have found meaning in your own roles as mothers.

25 Responses to “Guest Post: Rachel”
  1. emilydeon says:

    I read a life changing book last year called “The Gift of Pain”. It’s an easy read and totally engrossing. I’ll bet you’d love it.!

    If you DO read it, let me know what you think of it on MY blog! :) Emily at http://www.actegratuit.blogspot.com


  2. “Why would any of us choose to feel pain when it can easily be taken away? ”

    I guess I’m in the “No pain? That’s awesome!” camp rather than the “no pain no gain” perspective. Usually the worst thing I have to complain about after a birth is the stupid IV. I hate IVs. I do admire those who decide to go without medication, though. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

  3. chickymama says:

    By child #4 I realized that epidurals don’t ‘take’ with me. I get all the numbness in my foot and none where I really need it. So if there is a #5 what will I do? I don’t know, but I appreciate hearing other views and how people do it and why.

  4. KrisandCo says:

    After having 4 kids, I found epidurals only worked for me 50% of the time. I decided for my 5th baby to go completely natural. It was incredibly liberating to not be hooked up with needles and IV’s. I loved the freedom it gave me. Yes, it got very intense, but it made a huge difference for me being prepared and having chosen that intensity rather than being surprised with it (like when the epidural didn’t work out!)

  5. IamLoW says:

    Another really good book on birthing is Silent Knife. It’s about the c-section epidemic. It gave me the courage to try the all natural approach after 2 c-sections. It was BY FAR the best birthing experience ever. What a nice natural “I am woman, hear me roar!” high! :)

  6. emilylf says:

    I had an epidural with my first but not my second. As I was crying when the anesthesiologist said he didn’t feel comfortable giving me an epidural and saying “I’m not one of those women, I can’t do this without an epidural!” he surprised me by saying that more than 50% of the population have epidural-free births. I was shocked.

    And I did it.

    But I would never do it again, if I had the choice.


  7. #1 I had an epidural (had to be juiced up twice) administered by a GOOD anesthesiologist. #2 I had an epidural administered by a not so good anesthesiologist and my legs only tingled (the OB touched me and I yelped and he turned to the guy and said, “Why is she so jumpy!”) I felt everything and I thought it an insult that I was still charged for the epidural. I figured why pay for something that isn’t going to work? #3 was thankfully a different hospital/OB and with an incredible nurse that helped me during labor. Still had to have an IV because the kid needed to come out and wasn’t coming fast enough. Pitocin sure speeds things up. #4 was a different hospital/different OB and not quite as good nurse, but got through it. (Nurse even called me “macho woman” because there were no drugs.

    I didn’t get any spiritual uplift from the natural pain. It was work I had to do, and I was grateful I was able to do it. It just comes with the job. I did notice thought that I felt a lot better after the birth without the epidural than with one. I was more alert and awake after a natural birth than a drugged one. No new mom gets sleep, but I felt like I was recovering for weeks after my first.

    Sorry this was so long. I figure if an epidural is how you want to go, do it. If natural is better for you, do it.

  8. Momof4boys says:

    What a beautifully-worded post about natural birth! I have planned natural births with all four of my children. My first ended up in a c-section based on my son’s bad position, but my other three have been all-natural, with the last two born at home. It has been an incredible experience, beautiful and spiritual for sure. I am excited to look at your blog.

  9. Julie K says:

    1st Fantastic epidural
    2nd Lame epidural
    3rd/4th Transverse breach twins–c-section
    And then for the 5th and final kid, (4th birth):
    Labor went so fast and the anesthesia guy was so slow, I labored the whole way by myself (unwittingly). The epidural doc checked me before he began his job and I was a 6 but 45 minutes later and he was still trying to get the needle in the right place, I had passed to a 10 without anyone knowing it. Finally at 9:57 pm he had me lie back and he said “You are going to feel so much better in about 5 minutes”. At 10:04 pm I suddenly felt a “thunk” and I told the nurse (maybe I kinda yelled this?) ” I have never done natural labor so maybe I’m wrong but I think that was the head!” And it was. My baby was delivered right then and the doc was right, I felt soooo much better, just in time for my 2 stitches.
    I was shocked that it didn’t hurt as much as I would have thought. I think for me it really helped that I didn’t know how far I had gotten. I certainly wasn’t all chatty and joking around–I had laid on my side clutching the rail of the bed the whole time slow doc was working. But I wasn’t crying out and I was able to get through it quite easily, all things considered. I won’t be getting pregnant again (barring any miraculous events) but if I was planning on more kids I would definitely do it without the drugs, because I know I can.

  10. jennie w. says:

    I went natural with baby #5 of 6. It was awful and I would never do it again. I was in so much pain I didn’t want to hold my baby. Or even open my eyes to look at her. Where is the beauty in that?

  11. Angela says:

    I’m with jennie w. on that one. #2 epidural didn’t work in time and all I remember about the delivery was the pain. I did recover faster but it certainly wasn’t worth the pain. #3 I had an epidural and was also induced. It was absolutely fantastic. I really wanted to be up and about as fast as I was with #2 so I tried and I was able to do it. I wonder if it’s just with your first that you feel wiped out for so long.
    It’s possible that I briefly felt a connection between the pain and rejoicing in the birth, but that was soon overshadowed by my natural love and concern for my baby that I would have felt with or without the pain.

  12. Julie says:

    I certainly don’t want to stir up controversy or hurt anyone’s feelings, but I have to admit that I do not see the point of giving birth without an epidural. I feel many women use “natural birth” as a way to feel superior to other women, as if their desire to feel pain in childbirth says something about their mothering abilities. Are our worlds so small as women that we must find what we believe is empowerment in a natural body function? Really, anyone can give birth without an epidural. There’s no trick to it. It happens in every country of the world every day without any special preparation on the woman’s part. But why should we? What is the big deal? I guess maybe I should read Rachel’s blog.

  13. Thora says:

    I had a sister in my ward when I lived in England who was a doula and helped me prepare for my second natural birth. She talked about how giving birth was the only life giving pain besides the Atonement, and that it’s not suffering in vain, like injuries or illness. Because of that the pain is different. Having had appendicitis, I can certainly testify that for me the pain of childbirth, knowing that it’s for something, for giving life, changes my experience of the pain. It doesn’t take it away, but it does give me focus, give me reason to go through it (and I personally am generally in favor of natural childbirth not for the pain, but rather for less health risks than are associated with epidurals and C-sections).

    Also I think preparing for childbirth helps with a natural experience, and not just being caught in it.

  14. grannybabs says:

    I don’t think women “go natural” to somehow look superior. I don’t mean to stir up controversy or hurt anyone’s feelings either, but that is a pretty divisive attitude to take.

    I’m older than most of you, I’m sure, and my first birth was “natural” in the sense that there was no pain medication. But there was no preparation either.

    The second birth was quicker and drug free too – mainly because they didn’t offer it and since I had gotten by without it the first time, I didn’t ask for it.

    The third birth was not so quick – and so they gave me Pitocin – without telling me that was what they were doing. It was awful!! You all need to be grateful that you are all so much better informed now.

    Birth number four came 12 years after birth number one, and I finally knew enough to ask for what I needed. I attended classes, read books, and had a great experience – that was also drug-free, but I had wonderful nurses who truly made all the difference.

    By the time birth number five came around, I got really smart and attended pre-natal exercise classes and really prepared myself. And I had the best birth experience ever. It was life-changing for me.

    By the time baby number six came, I was 42 years old – taking care of teens and toddlers – and didn’t prepare as well – and so the birth experience was much more difficult.

    I think it’s all about preparation.

    I don’t fault women who have epidurals and are induced – as long as it’s an informed choice.

    We should all be open to new and possibly life-changing experiences.

    And we should never judge other women’s birth experiences.

  15. cuppycake says:

    I had my first two babies at home with no pain relief. After the first one I actually found myself wondering why it gets so over dramatised on tv and in movies. It really wasn’t as bad as I had anticipated. My 3rd was in a hospital because we moved and here they don’t do homebirths for free. All three were drug/intervention free natural births however and after number 3 I walked out of the hospital a few hours later and carried on with my day, cleaning, taking care of the other kids and even shopping. I really don’t think i would have been able to do that if I’d been given drugs etc.

  16. Julie K says:

    Grannybabs: You just proved what I have been suspecting for a while. You rock.

  17. grannybabs says:

    As an English teacher I am mortified to note that I wrote “women’s” when I should have written “woman’s” – chalk it up to the late hour and my advanced (ha, ha) years.

    I just hope one of my kids doesn’t read it – I will never live it down! (I’m the sort of English teacher who seems to automatically correct even the grammar of perfect strangers. My children fault me for this – as well they should. My own sister says she doesn’t write me letters because she imagines me reading them with a red pencil. I need to do something about that!)

    Talk about a non sequitur.

  18. Rachel says:

    I love the LRS community. I think it’s always good to think about differing approaches and views, even when they aren’t necessarily ones you would choose.

  19. grannybabs says:

    This is why I try to avoid the possessive. I’m thinking it should either be “other womens’” or else it should be “another woman’s.”

    Where are the editors when you need them??

  20. Filosofia says:

    Here I am. “Other women’s” was correct. There is no such word as “womens.”

    I don’t think Julie’s comment was divisive at all. I do think saying “I don’t fault women who have epidurals” presupposes that it is possible to fault them at all. That makes no sense to me. It’s like saying, “I don’t fault women who have appendectomies, or root canals, or colonoscopies.” Accepting pain relief in a day and age when it is blessedly available seems like the sensible thing to do. I have given birth four times: once with an epidural, and three times without, although I desperately wanted one. I can say, twenty years later, that those birth experiences have no bearing whatever on the real mothering that has taken place in the interim. I don’t feel any closer to the non-epidural kids or look back with more fondness at their birth. Women do tend to make a hobby out of childbirth and how they can do it best, without considering that it’s a mere blip on the timeline of motherhood.

  21. cadji says:

    If anyone is still reading this, you might find interesting a documentary Ricki Lake did. It’s called “The Business of Being Born.” If you choose an induction and epidural or other pain med, that’s fine. Just make sure you are informed and it is your choice.

    That said, I’m a mom to 4 boys. My first was born in the ambulance (long story), so no pain meds. With the next, I thought if I could do it medication-free the first time, certainly I could do it again. Then with numbers 3 and 4, I couldn’t very well wuss out and take medication, right? All my births have been very positive experiences, although I have had to fight with nurses/docs to have a medication-free delivery. I just don’t think they know what to do with me. Also, my husband thinks I am nuts to turn down the drugs.

  22. grannybabs says:

    That film was great – very informative and somewhat inspiring.

    That(that is, many of the experiences relayed in the film) is what I mean about informed choice – epidurals are not always fine – I’ve heard too many first hand stories about complications with them. I suppose I should have said birth choices are just that – choices – and we need to respect one another’s choices. In the face of elective surgery, it’s probably important to be informed about what they plan to use also.

    I think sometimes we trust doctors too much. They are great – but it behooves us to be informed – and a good doctor won’t mind if you question things.

    And thanks for the grammar checkup – I truly have avoided the possessive most of my life because even though I can quote the rules, I have always gotten confused applying them.

    Don’t let my students know that though. (Although I always tell them how you can get around the possessive – in case they are challenged like me!)

  23. rachelleavitt says:

    I have been very informed through this conversation so thank-you ladies:) Obviously, my perspective comes from one of natural birth. That and the fact that I work with new moms and babies all the time, so I think I tend to get obsessive about this whole birth thing:). What it comes down to for me though, is why should be have to just endure something that is such a big part of how life is brought here. Why can’t we find meaning in it? And why can’t we apply that to how we become as a person and as mothers? I don’t think this is just done by natural births either. I think anyone can have a meaningful childbirth, from the super natural born at home moms, to the c-sections.

    I look back on my experiences in child birth and they have definitely shaped me as a person. There are times when I am sitting in Sun. School or RS and something clicks within me because of my experiences with childbirth. For example, we were talking this Sun. about how we will have to endure pain as we wait for the second coming. And as we were talking about this I thought..ok, I can endure pain because I know what it feels like once that pain stops and we have a promise of new life. I felt that in labor.

    Not to say that you can’t understand this if you haven’t experienced labor, but that I found meaning in my labor that has helped me to understand things better. What it comes down to for me, is that we should always be finding ways to strengthen ourselves through our experiences. Labor and birth is just one of those times that we can utilize to find more meaning in our lives.

  24. Julie says:

    Thank you for weighing in, rachelleavitt. I think I better understand why you find such significance and beauty in drug-free birth. I really respect that. I worry, though, that natural birth advocacy puts undue pressure on women to feel pain in childbirth, pain from which they might not cull any spiritual benefits as you do. And that if they decide they’d rather not feel the pain anymore, they are “wussing out,” as cadji put it. That choosing an epidural indicates that they are less capable, less spiritual, or at the very least, less impressive mothers than women who choose drug-free birth.

    And grannybabs, I think you are right: “superior” is too strong a word. I think what I was getting at is that many women use natural childbirth as a way to feel special. Among middle- and upper-class women of the Western world it is remarkable for a woman to give birth without drugs, it’s true. But globally, there is nothing special about natural birth. Women everywhere do it every day without the help of prenatal classes, certified doulas, labor tubs or hypnosis. Anyone can do it. Whether or not the mother feels the pain of childbirth, the baby arrives. And that, to me, is the miracle of birth: that a new life comes into the world, and not that the mother performed a heroic sacrifice.

  25. rachelleavitt says:

    I have seen three camps on this issue. Those who give natural birth and are revolted by those who who don’t. Those that have a medical birth and are revolted by those who do and those who are in the middle somewhere along that spectrum. I think 1% of the people belong in either of the first two camps, but unfortunately those are the two camps we focus on. In reality, most people are somewhere in between and honestly trying to figure what exactly is the best for them:) I would really like to reach out to all people and help them have better births. So, like I said to all here, thanks for your input and if you want send an e-mail my way and let me know what your experience was like with birth and how it could be better. I also use this to better my practice as a nurse that works with moms/babes. Your stories and viewpoints help me a lot! Rachel

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment. First time users must register before logging in.